| 
                          
                      
  | 
                       
                         Faster Than Light  
                          Transmission of Signals 
                        | 
                     
                     
                      | 
                         Prof. Dr. Guenter Nimtz 
                        | 
                       
                         Original article  
                          by E. Habich 
                        | 
                     
                   
                   
                  Background: 
                    Superluminal tunneling (faster than light transmission 
                    of signals) was first observed at the University of Cologne 
                    with microwave photons. Soon thereafter these experiments 
                    were duplicated and validated at the University of Berkeley 
                    and Vienna. For theoretical physics the implication is that 
                    there exist spaces, devoid of time. 
                   
                    9th September 1999: Having met Prof. Dr. Nimtz for the first time 
                      I was shown his new tunneling experiment. As a lay person 
                      I'm not able to launch immediately into an in-depth scientific 
                      interpretation of his experiment but I will dutifully try 
                      to comprehend what I saw today, and try and share my insights 
                      and questions and make the data available as they become 
                      known. 
                    I present here for the first time world-exclusive 
                      pictures of Prof. Nimtz's new experiment setup.  For 
                      further background information: click 
                      here 
                   
                   
                  Prof. 
                    Dr. Nimtz present experiment takes it's inspiration from an 
                    experiment by Jagadis 
                    Chandra Bose, an Indian physicist born in 1858. Bose's 
                    successful public demonstration of remote signaling with radio 
                    waves in 1895 predate Marconi's experiments by two years. 
                    In 1897 Bose carried out experiments with semiconductors at 
                    frequencies as high as 60 GHz and was in the opinion of Sir 
                    Neville Mott, Nobel Laureate in 1977, at least 60 years ahead 
                    of his time. 
                    
                    Bose's 1897 diagram of a double-prism 
                   
                   
                  Modern 
                    measuring devices make it possible to investigate the effects 
                    of total reflection in more detail and to compare the results 
                    with what is known these days about quantum tunneling. 
                   The 
                    new experiment of Prof. Nimtz explores total internal reflection 
                    of micro waves inside a dielectric prism, and the effect and 
                    characteristics of a small air gap between two identical prisms. 
                    One known effect of quantum tunneling is the propagation 
                    of photons at speeds much faster than light. The exact measure 
                    of this effect is as yet unknown in this setup. Previous tunneling 
                    experiments in different constellations have shown superluminal 
                    effects of up to 30x the speed of light. 
                    
                   The 
                    complete setup shows the transmitting antenna at the left, 
                    with the receiving antenna at the right. 
                    
                    
                   
                   Prof. 
                    Nimtz explaining the tunneling effect on the dielectric prism. 
                    The modulation of the microwave is approx. 1Ghz. and has a 
                    wavelength of 3cm. The gap between the prisms is 5cm, and 
                    tunneling takes place. Prof. Nimtz: "The 
                    waves enter on the left and are being reflected totally on 
                    the first wall. Only when the distance between the two prisms 
                    is not too great the can signal tunnel through the gap. It 
                    looks as if this gap here is the tunnel barrier. When we increase 
                    the gap the signal intensity received at the other end decreases. 
                    This has already been shown by Bose in 1897. But the time 
                    in which the signal traverses the tunnel has not been reliably 
                    measured until now."  
                   
                    
                    The photon microwave transmitter in detail 
                    
                    The receiver in close-up 
                   
                   The 
                    monitor on the left of the setup. shows the tunneled signal 
                    arriving at the receiver on the left. 
                    
                   
                   This 
                    view shows the experiment from the vantage point of the receiving 
                    antenna. Clearly visible is that the receiving antenna is 
                    connected directly with the oscilloscope. 
                   
                   The 
                    7854 oscilloscope used in this demonstration. 99.999% of the 
                    emitted signal does not get tunneled.  
                    
                    
                    
                    
                   
                   Shown 
                    is an interruption of the microwave beam by Astrid, causing 
                    a flat line on the oscilloscope. In a working experiment setup. 
                    the prism is shielded with insulating material, to eliminate 
                    parasite waves.  
                   
                   Prof. 
                    Dr. Nimtz demonstrating the effects of mirroring with a metal 
                    plate. The emerging signal is reflected back into the prism 
                    where it changes the characteristics of the tunneled signal. 
                    
                    
                    
                    
                    
                   
                   This 
                    is the old tunnel type used in experiments as described  
                    in the media previously. Prof. Nimtz: "Until 
                    now we never worked with an experimental setup like the double 
                    prism. Our experiments were always confined to enclosed wave 
                    guides. It is easier to derive exact time measurements from 
                    enclosed wave guides." 
                     
                    
                   
                   Here 
                    is another tunnel design. Speeds measured on this device exceeded 
                    9x the speed of light, within the frame of reference of this 
                    tunnel. The speed is achieved by the staggered effect of repeated 
                    change from Perspex to air. 
                    
                    
                    
                   
                  Shown is a 
                    diagram, which appeared in a similar version in the European 
                    Physical Journal B, J.B.7,523. It illustrates the intensity 
                    of the tunneled signal versus time of a normal airborne photon 
                    moving from right to left:  
                    
                  The airborne 
                    signal is shown as a solid line and the tunneled signal is 
                    shown as dots. Both fronts (waves) have traversed the same 
                    distance in the same time, with the light velocity of c. 
                    Here "d" is the maximum of the tunneled pulse, "a" 
                    is the shift of the maximum, "o" is the variance 
                    of the tunneled signal and o0 is the variance of the incoming 
                    pulse. The frequency spectrum can be infinite. 
                  The superluminal signal does not travel back in time! 
                    Instead it arrives before the normal speed 
                    photons. The distance which the signal can theoretically traverse 
                    at superluminal speed is given by the maximum of the untunneled 
                    wave. 
                  The velocity of the tunneled signal is measured against 
                    the velocity of a signal not being tunneled.  
                  In the case of unlimited frequency bands the high-energy 
                    components do not tunnel in the wave-mechanical barrier. According 
                    to Nimtz these high energy components form a front which travels 
                    with the speed of light and cannot be 
                    overtaken by the low frequency superluminal tunneling modes. 
                    The superluminal signals are shifted to earlier pulse arrival 
                    time. They overtake the front of the signal traveling at light 
                    speed and are thus not violating Einstein causality. 
                  We cannot observe any 
                    signal moving faster than light! Nimtz explains 
                    it thus: "The analogy between the Schroedinger equation 
                    and the Helmholtz equation holds true. It is not possible 
                    to measure an evanescent mode. Obviously evanescent modes 
                    are not directly measurable in analogy to a particle in a 
                    tunnel." 
                     
                    What are evanescent modes? Nimtz describes these as low-frequency 
                    superluminal tunneling modes, which have a lower energy-content 
                    than the potential barrier. 
                   
                  Due to the large number of questions raised by this 
                    experiment I have decided to enable our readers to review 
                    the "Annalen der Physik, Leipzig, 7, (1998) 7-8, pages 
                    618-624." I hope this article by Prof. Dr. Nimtz, which 
                    is intended to be shown here for review only, will lead to 
                    a better understanding. I am publishing the paper without 
                    alterations, so as to avoid misinterpretations and further 
                    confusion.  
                  Click 
                    here for  
                    "SUPERLUMINAL SIGNAL VELOCITY"  
                    by G. Nimtz. 
                   
                  Acknowledgments: 
                    I would like to thank Prof. Nimtz for taking the time 
                    to explain his experiments to me in detail 
                    Thanks to Darrel Emerson, for the use of the Bose diagram. 
                   
                 |